Jump to content
Jedi Phoenix

First sig in a while


TheFredz

Recommended Posts

Not bad, the bit up top just behind his head could be removed (the one which is yellow-y/gold) and the right side top has some random curve effect which is...well unusual :p

 

Likin' the idea of the spikes on the back but the renders been erased a bit and could work blending. Oh and topaz (:p) and depth needs to be changed for sure.

Still, for a long time out good one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not trolling at all.... I just find it funny that you would patronize me about depth and blending while the Sig you made and are using right now is as flat as a pancake and have no blending whatsoever.

 

I was asked to come out with a zombie themed Sig that has nothing to do with L4D. It's not as easy as it sound to find decent material to work with.

 

I challenge you to come up with something better

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Woah, slow down there fellahs before the testosterone levels fly through the roof.

 

Fredz, Kfalc's comments appeared to be reasonably constructive; if his suggestions were impossible to implement then that's fine, just say so.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not trolling at all.... I just find it funny that you would patronize me about depth and blending while the Sig you made and are using right now is as flat as a pancake and have no blending whatsoever.

 

I was asked to come out with a zombie themed Sig that has nothing to do with L4D. It's not as easy as it sound to find decent material to work with.

 

I challenge you to come up with something better

 

This sig I'm using wasn't meant to have depth in it, its more of a vector style (plus depth in this sig if you imagine it, would look dire). The only blending I have done is with the colours/effects overlap in mine, and they match and thats all I attempted, it was nothing like I normally do (which is using C4D's mostly, as you should know - Plus its the first one I had made in ages - So a time gap and a total new style which is meant to be amazing on my first go? No, nor did I expect it to be much better, I don't know about you).

 

Also maybe you should think about this: You don't have to have a GREAT signature showing, or be amazing at art or even know how to use photoshop/GIMP etc to be able to give constructive criticism. Grow some skin and deal with the criticism, because that's what CnC is all about. You didn't ask for it, but you don't show a piece unless you want some comments on it, and as nice as it is for most people to tell you its cool etc, I just gave you some comments about stuff you could perhaps improve on for your next one.

 

You've taken the criticism of the material wrongly - Its not a criticism of you at all, I know how hard it is to find stuff when you're looking for it and zombie stuff is annoying because there's not much in the way of high quality usable material. Remember? I did used to do this as much as you did.

 

You challenge me? Did I claim I could do better? No, both of us know that you can make this better than what you have done there (after some practice) and there is no need for this. As for the shake of the head emoticon you put up as you obviously think you much better regardless of if I produce anything and no matter what I say.

I'm curious, would you have replied in the same manner if someone else, lets say soli or knightfire, told you how you could improve it? Or is it just because it's me?

 

(Because I know we didn't see eye to eye in the end but it's not like we can't start over with a new slate)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

would you have replied in the same manner if someone else, lets say soli or knightfire, told you how you could improve it? Or is it just because it's me?

 

You never post on anyone showoff threads but mine even people who asked for CnC. From reading your eye to eye comment you obviously have a grunge against me for some reason but I don't ever remember ever having a problem with you before and has soli, knightfire or anyone else been singled me out and posted in such a patronizing way as you been doing I would have responded in the exact same way.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You never post on anyone showoff threads but mine even people who asked for CnC. From reading your eye to eye comment you obviously have a grunge against me for some reason but I don't ever remember ever having a problem with you before and has soli, knightfire or anyone else been singled me out and posted in such a patronizing way as you been doing I would have responded in the exact same way.

 

Not true, I've posted on saber's thread before (somewhere) and I talk to other people and give CnC via xfire/msn (I've done it for knightfire and others before in the past). Wait, am I not allowed to post on my own clan forums where I want, when I feel like? I merely posted here for the sake of seeing what you made after such a long time (having seen nearly all of your old work - I was interested to see what kinda thing you'd try and how it would turn out).

 

Really? from reading my original first post you figure I have a grudge when your the one who posted acting as if your better than me for no reason in your response? Okay then mate. I was merely trying to be be helpful, and you just threw it back in my face and said: "I'm above you".

 

Patronizing: Treat with an apparent kindness that betrays a feeling of superiority.

 

My first post was in no way patronizing - I have a sig with no depth, yet I say yours could do with some because the TYPE of sig you have done would look slightly better (imo) with depth and a bit more blending - thats called constructive criticism, yet I stated it was good for you having not done one in so long. But you've made a something out of nothing comment. I think you are being patronizing with your responses to me.

I don't have a grudge with you, like I said its pretty much a clean slate after all this time we haven't spoken.

 

But fine, enough of this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not true, I've posted on saber's thread before (somewhere) and I talk to other people and give CnC via xfire/msn (I've done it for knightfire and others before in the past). Wait, am I not allowed to post on my own clan forums where I want, when I feel like? I merely posted here for the sake of seeing what you made after such a long time (having seen nearly all of your old work - I was interested to see what kinda thing you'd try and how it would turn out).

 

Really? from reading my original first post you figure I have a grudge when your the one who posted acting as if your better than me for no reason in your response? Okay then mate. I was merely trying to be be helpful, and you just threw it back in my face and said: "I'm above you".

 

Patronizing: Treat with an apparent kindness that betrays a feeling of superiority.

 

My first post was in no way patronizing - I have a sig with no depth, yet I say yours could do with some because the TYPE of sig you have done would look slightly better (imo) with depth and a bit more blending - thats called constructive criticism, yet I stated it was good for you having not done one in so long. But you've made a something out of nothing comment. I think you are being patronizing with your responses to me.

I don't have a grudge with you, like I said its pretty much a clean slate after all this time we haven't spoken.

 

But fine, enough of this.

you wrote the definition of patronizing in your post and then claim I was the one patronizing.

 

Patronizing: Treat with an apparent kindness that betrays a feeling of superiority.

 

where can you find any apparent kindness in my posts.... you got under my skin I responded bluntly, With your 2nd and 3rd post it became apparent that you hold a grudge for some reason.

 

we should drop this pointless bickering as nothing good can come out of it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...